BUNCOMBE COUNTY REPUBLICAN PARTY

11th DISTRICT CONVENTION

 

March 10, 2007

 

 

         

Chairman George Keller called the meeting to order at 10:15 a.m. at A-B Tech’s Ferguson Auditorium.  Reverend Tom Rightmyer gave the invocation and George led the pledge of allegiance.

 

George introduced the officers – Chuck Durand, Vice-Chairman; Sandra Bradbury, Secretary; and Nancy Day, Treasurer.  For this convention, George appointed Sandra Bradbury as Secretary.  Angela Moore will be  Chairman of the Parliamentary Committee and committee members are Marie Ledbetter and Nathan Ramsey.  The Teller Committee consists of Sid Johnson, Carl Mumpower and Betty Budd.  Sergeant-at-Arms is Casey Reese.  Timer is Steve Duncan.

 

George introduced our newly elected Representative in Raleigh, Charles Thomas.  Charles said he was elected Chairman of this organization about six years ago and some things are different now.  If we continue with division and divisiveness, there is no way for Republicans to return to a majority in the House.  Madison wrote in the 1700’s about guarding against the evils of factions.  We know in the United States we have a fundamental equation of politics.  One-half “N” plus one equals 100%.  One-half the number of people plus one vote gets representation.  Third parties in this country are the result of fractures of existing parties or grew when another party came to power.  When we leave today, we have to pull together and remain united in the party’s mission to elect fellow Republicans to office.  Charles said he could use some help down there.

 

David Sawyer, Chairman of the 11th District and candidate for State Vice-Chairman, spoke next.  He said Republican conventions are being held today throughout North Carolina.  David brought the group greetings from our State Chairman, Linda Daves, who is running for re-election.  These conventions are meetings of grass roots Republicans to elect officers for the next two years.  2008 is a banner election year: Presidential, the entire Council of State, Governor, Senator, and send Heath Shuler back home.  The important point is to have an election today, then come out united to elect Republicans and remember the opponents are the Democrats.  The District Convention will be held April 28 at West Henderson High School, starting at 3:00 p.m.  Karl Rove will speak this year.  We anticipate having a number of candidates for Governor speak at the dinner.  The State Convention will be held June 1-3 in Charlotte.  David said those attending the convention today are delegates to those two conventions if they wish to go.  David said he appreciated our support for Linda Daves and himself.

 

Dr. Carl Mumpower, City Councilman, thanked George and Alice Keller for their service the past two years and thanked everyone for being present.  He has been on City Council five years.  Carl said it is a myth that one has to compromise values and principles to be effective.  One needs to look for common ground.  Carl said he does not pander to voters.  One has to be sincere and of good heart.  People are looking for something other than fog or liquid jello to hold onto.  It is another myth that one has to be angry and aggressive.  Carl said he is soft-spoken and will continue to be, but will not be weak or soft inside.  He thinks he has to be courteous, persistent and work harder than the opposition.  Carl said he has been a minority all five years, but he can be effective.  Jefferson said to stand like a rock behind your principle.  The public’s job is to make City Council accountable.  Carl does not believe that the conservative movement is gaining ground and he is not optimistic about the near-term future of the Republican Party.  It is too hard to tell the difference between Republicans and Democrats.  Carl feels we need to hold the Council accountable to stand for something we can be behind.

 

Nathan Ramsey, Chairman of the Buncombe County Commissioners, thanked George for his hard work.  He said George’s job was unappreciated, but critical.  Nathan was fortunate when he first ran to have a good Party Chairman.  All Party Chairmen work hard.  Whoever is elected today will do a great job.  Nathan said he won by 741 votes when he first ran.  A little hard work helped and made a difference.  In Buncombe County, we can win elections, but it’s not easy.  Nathan stands on positions he is comfortable with.  He will not sell his soul to have the easy route, but the narrow path is more difficult.  For the past 30 years, Republicans have won the presidential election in Buncombe County.  We do not want Heath Shuler up there.  Nathan thanked Representative Thomas and Carl Mumpower for what they do.  Congressman Shuler has said he is a conservative Democrat.  Nathan thought that was an oxymoron.  Shuler votes his interest groups that got him elected.  We lost a good Sheriff and Congressman Taylor.  Hopefully we can take back that seat.  We need good people to run for County Commissioner.  Selena Sullivan and Matt Hebb are running for City Council.  Nathan said his colleagues are being pulled to the left for a moratorium on construction.  They want blackouts on power to conserve electricity, but Nathan thinks people should have that choice.  Nathan said he appreciated our support and encouraged everyone to get behind whoever gets elected.  It takes a team.

 

Justice Bob Orr, a candidate for Governor, spoke next.  Twenty-four years ago on the 5th floor of the Buncombe County Courthouse, Orr said he was elected Chair of the Buncombe County Republican Party and he is now running for Governor.  He wants to see that there is some presence of Western North Carolina in the Raleigh power structure.  When President Bush campaigned in Greensboro, the power structure was based in the East and large metropolitan areas.  Orr’s family has been in Western North Carolina since the late 1700’s.  He has practiced law in Asheville and has worked to make North Carolina a 2-party state.  We cannot let it slide back into one-party domination.  Orr said he has been nominated by the Republican Party in five state-wide elections.  He has been elected four times state-wide, twice to the Court of Appeals and twice to the North Carolina Supreme Court.  Orr is confident he can win in 2008.  Republicans built this party by controlling the Governor’s office.  It has been 16 years since Jim Martin left office and it will have been 24 years since a Republican has been Governor of this state.  There are enormous issues of reform in education, business, ethics and open government.  We have to be the party of reform.  Reach out to all citizens who are not here today.  We have to be united and can win in 2008.  His campaign gives Orr an opportunity to keep coming back to Western North Carolina.  Orr said if he is elected he will be in Western North Carolina every month of every year.

 

Steve Duncan, candidate for the 11th District Chair, spoke next.  He was excited to see today’s crowd.  This convention is electing between two people to be Chair of this County.  Steve is running for the entire 11th Congressional District and no one has challenged him.  Steve has been involved in politics for 24 years.  He will not apologize for his faith or because he is an American citizen.  Steve is proud of his country.  The convention’s job today is to elect Republicans to all offices.  That work starts today after a Chairman is selected.  Steve challenged the convention to grow behind that person and expects us to work.

 

Eric Gorny spoke next for Marcus Kinley, a candidate for State Chairman.  Marcus wanted to be here but was unable.  He leads by example with a can-do attitude and hard work, by developing others, by building a team and by taking pleasure from the success of his teammates.  He wants to empower counties with funding to deal with candidates and reunite the party.  Marcus is now Chairman of the Guilford County Republican Party.  Eric said he actually answers his cell phone, is very sociable and gives direct answers.  Eric encouraged people to question Marcus.  He noted that Linda Daves is also a good candidate.

 

Matt Hebb, running for Asheville City Council, spoke next.  He wants to bring some honor back to the City.  Carl Mumpower is trying it alone.  Asheville needs good strong conservative Republicans and needs to be a business-friendly city.  Matt is fiscally conservative.  He admires Carl, but Carl is just one voice.  Matt is another one and he is not the same as Carl.  Matt will lead forward in a way that will make Republicans proud.  He asked the convention to vote for him or put a bumper sticker on their car.  Asheville is very important to the people in Buncombe County.  He encouraged people to get involved and also to support Selena Sullivan.  We can change Asheville from now into the future.  We need to save the city we love so much.  The 2007 election is very important.  It is the opening overtone for 2008.  If Republicans can win in Asheville, Matt assured the crowd they can win anywhere.

 

Selena Sullivan said she was officially running for Asheville City Council.  This convention is about leadership and we need it on the Council.  Carl needs help.  Selena said she is an effective proven leader and is not afraid of a fight.  She is a native of Asheville, a rare breed.  Selena has seen bad decisions being made on development.  She stands on the philosophy, teach a man to fish and he will eat for a lifetime.  We are moving toward a socialist society.  Next comes communism.  We have to shift the Democrats out.  Three seats are open and Selena plans to fill one of them.  She thanked the crowd for its support.

 

George said his motto for this election is, “Replace the baby.”

 

Robert Van Wagner, the Republican representative on the Buncombe County Board of Elections, gave an update on the voting machines.  We ended up with one vendor.  This is a system the BOE is not in favor of.  We can lose an election with one corrupt Democrat judge.  The vendor says we have to pay extra money to do all the forms.  We cannot take care of the machines.  About 20-25 people attended all of the BOE Board Meetings and hammered on the fact that this is the system we needed.  They convinced four of the five County Commissioners that the BOE was wrong.  Our system now has all BOE members concerned.  It worked out well last time.  The machine used to count ballots failed about forty times.  It is imperfect.  We had to replace the drive on it.  We have to have a paper trail.  Other states do not have this kind of problem.  Alice Silver is no longer employed and cannot be replaced until after June.  Contact Robert if anyone has any questions.  The technician who worked on the machines is on permanent disability.  Many people are moving into the county.  The BOE has added additional precincts and will probably have 8-10 more precincts by 2008.  The BOE recently purged records, but those updates will not affect 2007.  The next election will be in Weaverville on April 24.  The BOE checks votes afterwards.  Weaverville will vote for liquor by the drink and an ABC store.  We now have to have an additional precinct to handle some of the votes.

 

Republican Kids Club President Aaron Pettit spoke next.  The club’s service project fell through for this year.  They will get a new project and will update the website.  The club has designed some t-shirts.

 

Robin Ramsey, President of the Blue Ridge Republican Women’s Club, thanked all Precinct Chairs, officers and especially George and Alice.  She started in the BRRWC and has held every office except treasurer.  There is so much to do for 2008.  Joining a club gives one that direction as a group effort.  There are several clubs in which to get involved.

 

Kathie Lack, President of the Action Club, said her group was focusing on education of the voters about issues so they will make good choices on election day.  They need people committed to work year-around to educate people.  The club also needs money.  Kathie thanked George and Chuck for their hard work.

 

Matt Hebb, President of the Buncombe/Henderson County Young Republican Club, said they have a combined membership.  Members are between 18-40 years old and need to be involved.  Young Republicans are the future and will take over eventually.  Matt is trying to build the YR’s.  They are very important to our county.  He encouraged people to call him.  He wants to build the club up to be the best of any Young Republican Club.  More clubs are now being chartered in North Carolina than in years past and Young Republicans are making huge strides.  The new State YR Chair is Tim Cotton.  Matt said big things are coming.

 

Bill Porter, President of the Buncombe County Republican Men’s Club, spoke next.  This club has been around a long time.  They just joined the newly resurrected North Carolina Federation of Republican Mens Clubs.  They want to get ineffective Republicans activated.  There are enough Republicans to elect everybody in office if Republicans would go to the polls.  All men and ladies are invited to the meetings.  The club meets at the Corner Stone on the second Saturday of the month.  The next meeting will be April 14.  They eat breakfast and start the meeting at 8:00 a.m. 

 

It was noted that Ken Bagwell is a new grandfather.

 

Chuck Durand, Vice-Chairman of the Buncombe County Republican Party, said he was there to chide the group a little bit.  We have some problems to solve.  Chuck’s job has been with the workers.  He has been a Christian conservative Republican for over 50 years and has served America over forty years.  Chuck has learned to bring people together.  That is the job of the new Chair and Vice-Chair.  He learned from President Reagan you can get a lot more done if you forget who gets credit or takes blame.  Past elections have been influenced using the Democrats’ credo that the end always justifies the means.  They are trying to destroy the Republican Party by dividing us, but will ultimately fail.  As shown in the last election, the best team doesn’t always win.  Charles Thomas now represents us in Raleigh.  We are under divisive attack.  There is talk that a shadow party tells our party leadership what to do and when to do it.  People in the military are called losers.  Chuck said military leadership is the most sought-after anywhere.  Elections are almost upon us.  We are independent-minded and must work hard in the future to bring people together.  The Democrats are trying to divide us.  In 2005, Republicans came together in the City election.  County Precinct Chairmen helped City Precinct Chairmen.  The County has a dog in the City fight.  In 2006, Precinct Chairs took over for missing Precinct Chairs.  This was another first.  Those Chairmen were very responsible.  We had 750 party workers.  We campaign for the candidates and keep Democrats from stealing the election.  The BOE is great to work with, but they are also great at changing ground rules at the 11th hour.  That makes people angry at Chuck.  He said the convention will vote on changes today to make our party stronger.

 

George Keller said this was an unusual year.  He presented a Constituent Service Award to Congressman Charles Taylor for 16 years in the United States House of Representatives.  Congressman Taylor left a big hole.  Maybe in two or three years Shuler might pick up some of the work.  (Congressman Taylor was not present.)

 

George presented a Move Forward Award to Wilma Sherrill for her efforts on behalf of women and children.  She served us for a long time in the State House.  (Wilma Sherrill was not present.)

 

George presented a Fly In The Ointment Award to Carl Mumpower, a leader who votes his principles every time.  Carl accepted the award and said it is the first one he has received in five years. 

 

The Solid Rock Award went to Chuck and Mary Ann Durand for his hard work and undergirding of all Buncombe County Republican work for the past two years.

 

The Keep On Keeping On Award was presented to Frances Cosgrove for always doing her very best to do her job and more for the Buncombe County Republican Party.  Chuck said that Frances has been an Area Coordinator, the only one he really ever tangled with.  He was working the polls one time and mid-morning Frances came by to see if he was really there.  She came back again later to see if he was still there.  Chuck said she is a good lady and accountable.

 

Steve Starnes received the Most Persuasive Recruiter for Poll Workers Award.  He has since resigned.  (Steve Starnes was not present.)

 

Finally, George said the Volunteer Award went to Kathy Rhodarmer.  She has been involved in many activities in support of the Buncombe County Republican Party for several years.

 

George said being Chairman of the Buncombe County Republican Party was his joy and pleasure for the past two years.  We have added several Republican clubs and have a year-round headquarters for the party.  We had a near-complete slate for Republicans.  We supported candidates in 2005-2006 and it was a tough two years to support candidates.  The national tidal wave really affected us.  George felt sure this convention will elect good leadership for the next two years.  He encouraged them to elect who they would work for.  We are the players in the game and need volunteers.  We make phone calls.  We live in paradise.  Let’s continue to fight and take it back.  Let’s do the work.

 

George appointed Steve Aceto as Temporary Convention Chair.  Steve said his main qualification is that he is Chairman of the Sewer Board. 

 

Credentials Committee Chair Beki Taylor gave the first report.  There are 149 duly registered Republicans present.  Beki moved that 149 duly registered Republicans be elected delegates to the convention.  The motion carried.  Beki asked how many guests were in the auditorium and many people stood up.  She welcomed them to the convention and asked all guests to move to a particular area. 

 

If anyone wished to speak, Steve Aceto asked them to rise to be recognized, state their name and Precinct number.

 

Chad Nesbitt (Prec. 53) asked if someone is a guest and a Buncombe County Republican, whether they can vote.  George said yes, if the person had registered by January 31.

 

Steve Aceto called for adoption of the agenda with one minor change.  An additional motion would be submitted to modify the BCGOP Structure.  Eric Gorny moved to add two people to the credentials.  Beki agreed.  The agenda was adopted with three instead of two motions to modify the BCGOP Structure.

 

Steve Aceto said adoption of Rules of the BCGOP Convention requires a 2/3rd vote.  George moved the rules be adopted.  Casey Reese (Prec. 14) seconded.  Steve Aceto suggested the convention adopt the rules as posted on the website.  The motion carried.

 

Beki gave the second report from the Credentials Committee.  There are now 150 delegates.  She moved all be eligible to go to the District and State Conventions.  The motion carried.

 

The Minutes of the 2006 BCGOP Convention were adopted by common consent.

 

George presented the Treasurer’s Report.  There were copies of the report on the table.  The last two years were different from other years.  There is some money in the bank after having supported candidates in 2005 and having a headquarters for 18 months.  Steve Aceto thanked Nancy Day for the report, which was adopted by common consent.

 

George moved the convention adopt the State Plan of Organization as the BCGOP Plan of Organization.  The motion was seconded by Linda Carol (Prec. 19.1).  The motion carried.

 

There were three motions to modify the BCGOP structure.  George read the following two motions.

 

1.     Move to modify the BCGOP Structure to specify two Vice Chairmen for the BCGOP, a First Vice Chairman for Organization and a Second Vice Chairman for Event Coordination.  The exact wording of the modified Structure is posted on our website, www.buncombegop.org.

 

2.     Move to add to the Powers and Duties of the County Central Committee a new paragraph E, to read:

 

“E.  If a member of the Central Committee has three consecutive unexcused absences from meetings of the Central Committee and the Executive Committee, that member shall be assumed to have resigned from the Central Committee of the Buncombe County Republican Party.”

 

Loree Pettit (Prec. 37) seconded the motion.  Dorothea Alderfer (Prec. 52) asked if this was effective immediately or in the future.  George said immediately.  Mike Harrison (Prec. 50.1) asked what has happened in the past years to create this proposal.  George replied events for fundraising back up badly on the Chairman.  The Vice-Chair gets totally swamped.  This is to free up the Chair.  The Lincoln-Reagan Day Dinner takes all of one’s time for a couple of months.  Tom Rightmyer (Prec. 28) said the person who organized the Lincoln-Reagan Day Dinner this year was Mike Harrison.  Bev Kirkland (Prec. 5) said this was discussed two years ago.  We did not do it, but we should have then.  The majority of the work that could have been done put a heavy load on the Chairman and the Vice-Chair.  Bev said she was greatly in favor of this.  The first motion carried.

 

The second motion, regarding tightening up attendance by the Central Committee, was read again by Sandra.  Kathie Lack (Prec. 50.1) seconded the motion.  Ed Osada (Prec. 8), asked what constitutes an unexcused absence.  George replied when neither the Chair, Vice-Chair nor Secretary had any idea a person would not be there.  Matt Hebb (Prec. 6.1) wanted to amend the motion to specify the definition of unexcused absence.  George consented to a friendly amendment. 

 

The definition of an unexcused absence would be, “An absence as defined either by the Chair, Vice-Chair or Secretary not being informed of the absence.”

 

Mark Delk (Prec. 30) wanted to change “unexcused” to “unannounced”.  Matt and George agreed to that.  Mike Harrison (Prec. 50.1) was concerned that a member of the Executive Committee could announce he would henceforth attend no meetings.  What would the penalty be?  Would there be any limitation on how many absences a person can announce or excuse?  Kathie Lack (Prec. 50.1) said we are watering this motion down.  The group cannot vote in Central Committee meetings because not enough people show up.  They need a functional group.  We have to hold people accountable.  They need to be there unless something serious is happening.  Billie Bennett (Prec. 68.1) asked why have three unexcused absences.  Why not two?

 

Steve Aceto said there was a motion on the floor which had been seconded and had two amendments.  Charles Thomas (Prec. 56) wanted to call the question.  Steve Duncan (Prec. 23.1) seconded Charles’ motion.  Those in favor were asked to stand and the Teller Committee counted voters.  There were 96 votes in favor and 26 votes opposed.  The motion carried.

 

Don Yelton (Prec. 41) introduced the third motion, as follows.

 

Motion to permit the Precinct Chairman to appoint a member of his precinct to attend the executive committee if they and the vice chairman cannot attend.

 

Every effort is being made to get attendance at the executive meetings.  Sometimes it is just not possible to be in two places at one time.  Therefore I make the motion that the Precinct Chair has the authority to appoint a proxy if none of the officers is able to attend.  It goes without saying that the person that the chair person would pick would be a responsible person and act on the behalf of that precinct.

 

Danny Roberts (Prec. 25) seconded the motion.  Bill Fishburne (Prec. 29.1) said he was against this motion.  The Government of the United States elects its representatives.  We do not have a government by appointed proxy.  Maureen Flagg-Webber (Prec. 52) said by saying not an elected officer of the precinct, it should be another elected official.  One or the other should attend.  Matt Hebb (Prec. 6.1) said he thought a Vice-Chair can go to meetings anyway.  Tom Rightmyer (Prec. 28) said he is a Precinct Chair and most of the time he has to recruit workers.  Tom thought Don Yelton’s motion was a good one.  It will make sure precincts are represented at meetings.

 

George said it is in our structure that a Vice-Chair or Secretary of the Precinct can attend meetings.  In the North Carolina organization there are reasons not to have such an amendment.  Proxy votes would probably be cast out.  Betty Budd (Prec. 18) thought we should have voted on Matt Hebb’s amendment by now.  Charles Thomas (Prec. 56) said in the early 2000’s, Lanier Cansler resigned from the State Legislature.  The executive body can appoint that replacement.  If we alter our Plan of Organization to not be in compliance with the State, they could disallow our appointment.  This is dangerous waters.  Charles asked that the convention consider tabling this motion until the next convention after legal review.  Betty Budd (Prec. 18) seconded the motion.  The motion carried.

 

Angela Moore thought we needed to go back and vote on Matt’s amendment.  Matt defined unexcused absence as “One not reported to the Chair, Vice-Chair or Secretary.”  Matt withdrew his motion.  Larry Moore (Prec. 40.1) said we voted on what the secretary read.   Steve said the motion now is George’s original amendment.  It was seconded.  Steve read the motion and used the word “unannounced” instead of “unexcused”.  The motion carried.

 

Beki said we have a late-comer.  She made a motion to seat the new member as a delegate to all three conventions.  The motion carried.

 

Maureen Flagg-Webber was Chair of the Nominating Committee.  Committee members were Eric Gorny, Ralph Eubanks and Jerry Orr.  Candidates for Chairman are Mike Harrison and Chad Nesbitt.  Maureen asked if there was anyone else who wished to be nominated.  There were no nominations from the floor.

 

Bill Fishburne said he was a former Chairman of the BCGOP.  He placed Michael Harrison in nomination for Chairman.  Mike is a retired Army Colonel and has worked hard for the party.  He has great character and integrity and has been successful in several walks of life.  Mike is married to Nona Jane and they have a farm in Barnardsville.  Mike is able to work with people from all walks of life.  He is able to serve us and lead us.  Bill felt Mike should receive the favor of the convention’s vote.  They will be well served.  Mike is in the best position in terms of knowing and understanding Buncombe County and to lead our party into the future.

 

Selena Sullivan nominated Chad Nesbitt for Chairman.  She has worked with him on many occasions.  Chad has the passion and the vision to lead this party into a new era.  He can speak to people in all walks of life to bring them into a point of unity.  We must go after the new people.  Selena said she is the result of someone getting the truth to her.  Chad Nesbitt has the ability to unify this party.  His business and marketing background are a key part to make the people of this area aware of the Republican Party.  Selena hoped the convention would give Chad its approval to take this party into a new era.

 

Mike Harrison said it was typical at political conventions to hear candidates beat their fists and tell all the things they would do in the future.  His wife will not let him get away with that.  Mike wanted to be clear.  He was not seeking election as Chairman to rise above others, for a title or for some personal advantage.  He has always felt an obligation to serve the country.  He takes pride in having been a leader in the greatest military in the world.  Mike’s purpose is to serve the members of this party and help find solutions to the problems we face.  He is not perfect, but he is too energetic to sit back in his rocking chair.  Mike wants to build a majority party in Buncombe County and support elections for our candidates.  We need to educate voters why Republicans can make a positive impact in their lives.  We need to register and recruit new Republican voters and help Republican candidates.  There is much work to be done.  We have to initiate an aggressive and innovative fundraising program.  We need to reward our successes.  The Lincoln-Reagan Day Dinner was fun.  Government in North Carolina is arrogant and often ignores the will of the people.  We need Republicans in all branches of government.  Political struggle is not for the timid.  The stakes are too high.  Mike has been a Republican since 1964.  He has been a candidate for County Commissioner and held many offices in local clubs.  He chaired the last Lincoln-Reagan Day Dinner.  Mike thanked all committee members who helped with that.  He does not shirk from hard work.  He supports small government, lower taxes and personal liberty.  He said a vote for Mike Harrison can make all the difference.

 

Chad Nesbitt spoke next.  First, he presented a gift to Ken Bagwell.   Then he told us why he wanted to be the next Buncombe County Republican Chairman   He was going to bring discipline to the Democrats.  Chad addressed Colonel Harrison and said, we have young men fighting for the red, white and blue and I can take on a bunch of hippies in downtown Asheville.  This party cannot afford to live on $2,000 a year.  Chad was looking for candidates.  He encouraged the convention to get the resignation of Wanda Greene and follow the lead of Carl Mumpower, R. L. Clark and John Rhodes.  Chad wanted people to know why he joined the Black National Republican Association.  It was not about color, it was about telling the truth.  The Democrats have been telling lies about the minorities and we will put a stop to it.  We have to put some excitement into this party or we will continue to lose elections.  Chad felt Rick Jenkins, our next Vice-Chairman, is our security weapon.  He first met Rick with a deer strapped to his car and said Rick can sell water to a drowning man.  The Republican Party is important to Chad’s family and his faith.  We have to make sure to put strong Republicans in office to take care of our Christian faith so our children can grow up and be safe.  Chad encouraged the convention to vote for him and Rick.  He asked God to bless the convention and the Republican Party.

 

At 12:50 p.m., Steve Aceto asked the Teller Committee to pass out ballots, then pick them up and count them.  The committee followed instructions and Betty Budd made the following report:

 

          Chad Nesbitt received 51 ballots

          Mike Harrison received 82 ballots

 

Steve Aceto congratulated Mike and thanked Chad for his candidacy.

 

Maureen said Richard Mills, candidate for First Vice-Chairman for Organization, was absent due to a death in his family.  He is an ex-lawyer and co-owner of Asheville Historic Trolley.  Richard lives in Asheville and is active in the Republican Party.  He is a strong Christian.  Richard’s wife, Ann, was Vice-President of the Buncombe County Republican Women’s Club.

 

Steve Aceto asked if there were any nominations from the floor and there were none.  Steve Duncan (Prec. 23.1) moved the nominations close and Chuck Durand (Prec. 59) seconded the motion.  The motion carried by acclamation.

 

 Maureen said the candidate for Second Vice-Chairman for Event Coordination is Rick Jenkins.  Kathie Lack (Prec. 50.1) nominated Nona Jane Harrison.  Barbara Fishburne (Prec. 29.1) seconded the motion.  Bob Jolly (Prec. 23) moved that nominations close.  The motion was seconded.

 

Kathie Lack said she did not prepare a speech.  Nona had just expressed an interest in coordinating events.  She has done things behind the scene.  We need interested people and Nona Jane is willing to do the job.

 

William M. Jenkins, candidate Rick Jenkins’ father, came to the podium to nominate his son.  He was not a delegate and Frances Cosgrove (Prec. 14) asked if it was proper for a non-delegate to make a speech.  Steve Aceto asked if Frances was objecting because Mr. Jenkins was a non-delegate and she said yes.  Angela, the Parliamentarian, said it should be put to a vote of the convention.  Mark Delk (Prec. 30) moved to suspend the rules to let a man’s daddy speak on his behalf.  Chad Nesbitt (Prec. 53) said George Keller had told him that Mr. Jenkins could speak.  The motion carried.

 

William M. Jenkins said he has been a preacher for over 50 years.  He said David was a great man and referred to Psalms 127.  Mr. Jenkins appreciated the Buncombe County Kids Club.  He thanked the people at the convention for producing a Republican Party.  He said he didn’t have too much more time, but would enjoy the Lord and politics as long as he lives.  Mr. Jenkins has been married 54 years and has two sons.  His younger son is in the military.  The oldest, with the convention’s help today, will start helping the Buncombe County Republican Party.

 

Nona Jane Harrison said she has helped her husband with his past three campaigns.  They spent 20 years in Washington, D.C.  She has worked for Congress and the Olympics as an Events Coordinator to keep them on budget.  Nona Jane said she throws parties all the time.  That is what she does.  She would like to give the Republican Party some class and style.  Nona Jane would appreciate the convention’s vote and would try to do the best that she can.

 

Rick Jenkins said he can throw a shindig as good as the next person.  He felt it was an honor to stand before this group and have his father say good words about him.  Rick’s father is his very best friend.  They are a close family.  Rick has been married for 16 years and he and his wife pass their values on to their two children.  Work is earned by the sweat of your brow.  Whatever it takes in the Republican Party, Rick is not afraid to go to work.  He knows how to farm, and it makes one humble.  The best thing Rick’s parents taught him is how to pray.  The people who own and run America are not the government.  It is the good people of America who work to live the American dream.  Rick wanted to thank Bill Fishburne.  Bill gave Rick a job and Rick is on the radio now.  Rick’s best friend is Chad Nesbitt.  They joined forces and had a television show.  Ken Bagwell was Rick’s partner for a year.  Rick always enjoys the stance former Senator R. L. Clark takes for the rights of the people of Western North Carolina.  Rick asked if anyone had been to the Republican Headquarters and said it was a shame.  Rick said he has got excitement.  He asked God to bless the country, county, state and everyone at the convention.

 

Timothy Hyatt (Prec. 68.1) felt this assembly should honor Mr. William Jenkins so he or anyone else wanting to make a speech would be allowed to do that and not be embarrassed.  Chad Nesbitt seconded the motion.  Steve Aceto said he had personally apologized to Mr. Jenkins.

 

Betty Budd of the Teller Committee gave the following results:

 

          59 votes for Rick Jenkins

          49 votes for Nona Jane Harrison

 

Steve Aceto thanked both candidates.

 

Maureen said George Keller and Ann Mills were candidates for Secretary.

 

Maureen said Ann was not able to be here today.  She was Vice-President of the Buncombe County Republican Women’s Club and is co-owner and manager of the Historic Trolley in Asheville.  Maureen hoped the convention would consider Ann.

 

George said he would be happy to be Secretary.  He knows what the job entails.

 

Loretta Reynolds (Prec. 9) moved that nominations be closed.  Deborah Yelton (Prec. 40.1) seconded the motion.  The motion carried.

 

A standing vote was taken and the Teller Committee reported:

 

          72 votes for George Keller

            7 votes for Ann Mills

 

Maureen said Ed Osada is the only candidate for Treasurer.  Betty Budd (Prec. 18) moved he be elected by acclamation.  Don Yelton (Prec. 40.1) seconded the motion and the motion carried.

 

Maureen read the list of nominees for At-Large Members of the Executive Committee, as follows (five members can be elected):

 

                   Loree Pettit

                   Anna Cannon

                   Matt Hebb

                   Selena Sullivan

                   Willa Grant

                   Maureen Flagg-Weber

 

Kathie Lack (Prec. 54.1) nominated Bill Reynolds.  Bill Lack (Prec. 161) seconded the motion.

 

Eric Gorny (Prec. 65) nominated Chad Nesbitt.  Kathy Rhodarmer (Prec. 47.1) seconded the motion.

 

Danny Roberts (Prec. 25) nominated Don Yelton.  Linda Caroll (Prec. 19.1) seconded the motion.

 

Danny Roberts (Prec. 25) nominated Paul Purdue.  Matt Hebb (Prec. 6.1) seconded the motion.

 

Beki asked if someone could be a Member-at-Large and an Area Coordinator.  George said it would be redundant.  They would already be on the Central and Executive Committees.

 

Bill Reynolds (Prec. 32) said he would no longer be an Area Coordinator after this meeting.

 

George said Precinct Chairs could be elected.  Presidents of the clubs are on the Central Committee already.  He wondered if Matt contemplated resigning as President of the YR’s when he makes a run for City Council.  Matt replied he will have to resign as President when he signs up to run for City Council. 

 

Chuck Durand (Prec. 59) said there is a section in the rules that someone can be a candidate and remain part of a club.  He asked what the rule was for candidates.  Bill Porter (Prec. 24) said you cannot be a Precinct Chairman and a candidate.  Matt said he had called the State about that.  He will have to resign because of the North Carolina Young Republican rules.  There is no legal requirement to relinquish party offices.  He has also talked to the Board of Elections.

 

Bill Lack (Prec. 161) wanted to know if it was physically possible to be a candidate and still give something to the local GOP.  Mark Delk (Prec. 30) thought there was an appropriate time to debate and an appropriate time to talk about candidates.  These issues should be brought up when they talk about qualifications.  Mark encouraged the group to get on with the vote.

 

Matt and Selena withdrew from nomination.

 

Nancy Nesbitt (Prec. 53) nominated Zora Hayes.  Selena Sullivan (Prec. 11.1) seconded the motion.

 

Frances Cosgrove (Prec. 14.1) nominated Nona Harrison.  Beki Taylor (Prec. 47.1) seconded the motion.

 

Mark Delk (Prec. 30) moved to close nominations.  Frank Bradshaw (Prec. 46) seconded the motion.  The motion carried.

 

The following candidates were nominated:

 

                             Loree Pettit

                             Anna Cannon

                             Maureen Flagg-Weber

                             Willa Grant

                             Don Yelton

                             Chad Nesbitt

                             Paul Purdue

                             Bill Reynolds

                             Zora Hayes

                             Nona Jane Harrison

 

The following candidates were elected:

 

                             Loree Pettit

                             Don Yelton

                             Bill Reynolds

                             Zora Hayes

                             Nona Jane Harrison

 

There were no Announcements and no Old Business.

 

Under New Business, Don Yelton (Prec. 40.1) proposed a resolution in support of John Rhodes Day, as follows:

 

Whereas, the pay to play atmosphere was created in our State Capitol by a select group of power brokers; and

 

Whereas, the tendency is to be rated ineffective if you do not go along to get along; and

 

Whereas, the manipulation of the committee structure and appointments is used as a reward for supporting the power structure and ignoring the platform of the Grand Old Party; and

 

Whereas, the pressure not to support our party caucus and stand for the ideals of the Republican Party of less government, lower taxes and more freedom is exerted by the political machine in Raleigh.

 

Now, therefore, be it resolved that the Buncombe County Convention of March 10, 2007, does honor a man that stood for honesty and sacrificed his personal gain.

 

And, this Convention does fully support the establishment of the John Rhodes Society of Honest Politicians begun here in Asheville NC on March 3, 2007.

 

And furthermore, be it resolved that the Buncombe County Republican Party does fully support, encourage and request that the Republican Party of North Carolina aid and support establishment of March 22nd as John Rhodes Day in Politics in North Carolina.

 

This said resolution was adopted by the Buncombe County Convention on March 10, 2007, with a majority of those attending supporting such resolution.

 

George Keller (Prec. 1) seconded the motion.  The motion carried.

 

Bill Fishburne (Prec. 29.1) read the following resolution:

 

Whereas Congressman Charles Taylor served the 11th Congressional District ably, well and with distinction for 16 years; and

 

Whereas he is a man of character with true family values; and

 

Whereas during his eight terms in Congress he helped his district and his country in many ways; and

 

Whereas his successor has failed to represent his district in many ways and has voted for the most liberal of Democrats, Nancy Pelosi, as Speaker of the House;

 

We express our deep gratitude to Charles Taylor and to his caring and capable staff, and express the will of this convention that Mr. Taylor is strongly urged to consider future public service to the citizens of Western North Carolina.

 

Bill Reynolds (Prec. 32) seconded the motion.  Linda Carol (Prec. 19.1) wanted to add a friendly amendment to strike the part about Heath Shuler.  She felt all of our leaders need support.  Bill Porter (Prec. 24) seconded the motion.  Bill Fishburne (Prec. 29.1) said if this is friendly, he will reject it.  Linda wanted to remove the following words:

 

“Whereas his successor has failed to represent his district in many ways and has voted for the most liberal of Democrats, Nancy Pelosi, as Speaker of the House”

 

Steve Duncan (Prec. 23.1) was opposed to the amendment.  He felt Shuler has not done what he said he would in his campaign.  Frank Bradshaw (Prec. 46.1) said when Heath Shuler was elected, everyone said they all knew where he was headed.  Bradshaw was not going to give Shuler a break.  Bill Porter (Prec. 24) supported the amendment and agreed with the comments about Heath Shuler.  Linda Carol (Prec. 19.1) said she wanted to honor Congressman Taylor and did not want anything to take away from the gratitude expressed to him.  She would be in favor of a separate resolution against Heath Shuler.  Bill Fishburne (Prec. 29.1) said if Linda would be so gracious as to write that second motion, okay.  In the absence of that, Bill stood by his original resolution.  Steve Duncan (Prec. 23.1) wanted to call for the question.  Dorothea Alderfer (Prec. 52) seconded the motion.  The motion carried.

 

A standing vote was taken for the amendment.  The Teller Committee reported:

 

                   19 votes for

                   24 votes against

 

The amendment failed.

 

A standing vote was taken for the resolution.  The Teller Committee reported:

 

                   32 votes for

                   13 votes against

 

The resolution carried.

 

Mike Harrison (Prec. 50.1) read the following resolution:

 

Whereas many Republican Party members in Buncombe County do not attend and participate in County Conventions due to physical infirmities, illness, the demands of family, employment or other reasons;

 

And whereas it is desirable to encourage voting by as many party members as possible;

 

And whereas voting by proxy is a well established voting procedure used by large organizations to increase voting participation by eligible voters;

 

Be it therefore resolved by the Buncombe County Republican Party that:

 

The Chair, BCGOP Party shall designate a special sub-Committee of the Executive Committee not later than June 30, 2007, to study the desirability, legality and feasibility of allowing absent members of the party to vote by proxy at County Conventions.  The sub-Committee shall report its findings in writing to the Executive Committee with a recommendation to approve or disapprove proxy voting not later than September 30, 2007.

 

Loretta Reynolds (Prec. 91.A) seconded the motion.  Mike said he has a blind neighbor and he knows about others who could give notarized or legal proxies.  Bill Porter (Prec. 24) said we did not know who candidates were going to be.  How can anyone give a proxy?  Linda Carol (Prec. 19.1) noted that the Plan of Organization says in Section 5.A that at precinct meetings there shall be no proxy voting.  At County Executive Meetings, there are no proxies.  So many unknowns would make it difficult.  Linda asked about teleconferencing.  Steve Aceto asked that she speak to the resolution. 

 

Mark Delk (Prec. 30) felt the group was not debating the merits of proxy voting.  Steve Duncan (Prec. 23.1) wanted to call the question.  Don Yelton (Prec. 41) thought the State Party would be looking at this.  Mike said he just wants to evaluate it.  The question was called and the motion carried with one opposing vote.

 

George passed the gavel to Mike.  Mike said he was honored and humbled to have been elected.  Now the work begins.  He knew some people had reasons if they voted against him.  He said everyone is a valued member of the party and Mike will depend on them to help him succeed.

         

The meeting adjourned at 2:30 p.m.

 

 

Respectfully submitted,

 

Sandra Bradbury, Secretary

Buncombe County Republican

 Executive Committee